A Slice of Something Special

Our Great Pie Hunt led us to a Dillsboro diner serving up more than homemade desserts.
There's something comforting about a slice of homemade pie. Maybe it's the flaky crust, the familiar flavors, or memories of sitting around Grandma's kitchen table. Pie has a way of making us slow down and savor something simple.
But where have all the homemade pies gone?
When we asked our members to recommend their favorite local pie, one comment caught our attention: Southeastern Indiana has become something of a "pie desert." After weeks of phone calls and visits to restaurants across our seven-county service territory, we began to agree. Finding a homemade slice isn't nearly as easy as it once was.

Fortunately, our search uncovered some sweet surprises. And one name came up more than any other: Janet's Diner in Dillsboro.
Worth the Drive
On a bustling Tuesday, we walked into Janet's and immediately understood its popularity. The dining room was full, delicious aromas drifted from the kitchen, and a handwritten sign near the entrance listed the day's desserts, including plenty of pie: rhubarb, Dutch apple, pecan, pumpkin, and more. We had found our kind of place.
Tables turned quickly as workers stopped for lunch, while others lingered over conversation. Our waitress was exceptionally friendly, knowledgeable, and made us feel like regulars.
The lunch specials were tempting. Chicken pot pie served over homemade biscuits and platters of chicken-fried steak piled over mashed potatoes made their way through the dining room. Our waitress recommended the hand-pressed burgers and the crowd-favorite Ricky Boy sandwich, featuring grilled ham.

I opted for another one of her suggestions - the hand-breaded chicken tender sandwich.
The tenders were among the best I've ever tasted, and even the garlic-buttered hoagie roll deserved a mention. My coworker's homemade chili coneys brought the familiar flavors of Cincinnati-style chili a little closer to home.
We even spotted fellow REMC employees enjoying lunch. When your coworkers spend their days traveling seven counties, you learn to trust their recommendations for a good meal. But we came for pie.
And Janet's delivered. Beautifully flaky crusts, fillings with just the right sweetness, and flavors that tasted like someone had taken the time to make them right. Every bite reminded us why homemade pie is worth seeking out.
A Family Tradition

Janet's story began in 2006, when Janet and Rick Beard opened the diner after Janet had spent more than two years serving customers at the same location.
Twenty years later, the restaurant remains in the family. Their son, Charlie Caldwell, who began working there at age 12, took over when his parents retired. During our visit, Charlie was right where he feels most at home: cooking in the kitchen.
That dedication has helped make Janet's a Dillsboro institution, recently recognized as Best Local Restaurant in the 2026 Best of SEI Awards.
But perhaps the most meaningful thing we discovered wasn't on the menu.
Near the entrance, a Pay-It-Forward wall was filled with prepaid meal receipts purchased by customers for neighbors who could use a meal. Anyone in need can enjoy the same welcoming table and home-cooked food. It's a simple act of kindness that says a great deal about this restaurant and the community surrounding it.
More Than a Slice

Maybe homemade pie is disappearing because it takes something our busy world doesn't always make room for: time, patience, and a little extra care.
At Janet's, those things are still on the menu.
Our Great Pie Hunt reminded us that the best local restaurants offer more than a good meal. They're gathering places where neighbors become friends, traditions carry on, and everyone has a place at the table.
And sometimes, the sweetest part of the experience isn't just the pie. It's everything that comes with it.
Where to Find a Slice
Our Great Pie Hunt uncovered some sweet spots across Southeastern Indiana. Here are a few local favorites worth a visit!
Dearborn County
Janet's Diner | 12805 North Street, Dillsboro
State Line Restaurant | 55 U.S. 50, Greendale
Jefferson County
The Attic Coffee Mill Café | 631 W. Main Street, Madison
Horst's Little Bakery Haus | 220 Clifty Drive, Madison
Jennings County
Sugar Brew Bakery | 9 W. Walnut Street, North Vernon
Ripley County
The Reservation Restaurant | 1001 N. Warpath Drive, Milan
Schmidt Bakery | 125 Batesville Shopping Village, Batesville
Switzerland County
Center Square Discount Grocery | 10390 N. State Road 56, Vevay
Swiss Café & Ice Cream | 805 E. Main Street, Vevay
Pie selections and availability may vary. We recommend calling ahead before making a special trip!



